5 Shifts Every Leader Needs to Figure Out to Lead into the Future

Share This Post

What got you here won’t get you there.

As much as you know that’s true, especially as you think about the new reality ahead, there’s probably something inside you that resists that.

I promise you there’s something inside me that resists the axiom.

Here’s what goes on in my head as I think about what got me here not getting me there…

  • But I’ve done well in the past…can’t that approach just work again?
  • I don’t know whether I have the energy to rethink everything again.
  • If I can get incremental results doing what I’m doing now, isn’t that good enough?

Can you relate?

Of course, as soon as I hear myself think those thoughts, I realize that’s a terrible way to lead. In light of the massive distortion we’ve all been through, what helped you make progress in the past as a leader probably won’t work as effectively in the future.

But the resistance to change is real.

Coming out of the pandemic, the years ahead will be years of big change for almost everyone: church leaders and business leaders included.

So what shifts do you need to make to ensure you’re up to the challenge?

Here are five things every leader has to figure out to lead well moving forward. Master these, and the future and the change it demands will be much easier to navigate.

1. Openness

When things don’t go the way you planned in leadership, it’s easy to grow more closed off, rather than more open.

On the one hand, openness to new ideas, new approaches, different perspectives, and fresh thinking would logically seem like the obvious thing to do.

But emotionally, staying open can be the hardest thing to do as a leader.

There are two reasons why you’ll close yourself off to new strategies unless you stop yourself.

First, you’re already overwhelmed, discouraged, and defeated. And when that happens, it’s easy to circle back to what you know or to what worked. This isn’t entirely bad, but it’s not sufficient. Sure, don’t throw the baby out with the bathwater, but simply repeating what’s bringing you diminishing returns is a bad idea.

Repeating what's bringing you diminishing returns is a bad idea.  Click To Tweet

The second reason you’ll resist staying open to new ideas is that you’re already confused. Trying new things can seem too risky, even more confusing, and complex.

For those reasons and more, many leaders do the opposite of what they should do when facing uncertainty—they become more closed, not more open.

It’s not that they’ll never open up. They will. But often, only after everything is collapsing.

That’s what happens whenever people hit rock bottom: You suddenly become open.

And by that time, so much damage has been done that it’s often too late.

Staying open in the midst of change, stagnation, and decline and changing along the way is a much better approach.

Closed leaders suddenly become open when everything is collapsing and they hit rock bottom. But by that time, so much damage has been done that it's often too late. Click To Tweet

2. Resilience

One of my favorite definitions of success is getting up one more time than you were knocked down.

That’s a decent working metaphor for resilience as well. Resilience is the ability to recover quickly from difficulties. Lately, there have been so many difficulties.

What makes you resilient?

The factors vary, but some staples for resilience include:

  • An optimistic outlook. As ‘pie in the sky’ as that may sound, it’s hard to lead from pessimism.
  • Proper rest. It’s amazing how a good night’s sleep changes so much.
  • Friends. Leadership is often lonely, but it doesn’t have to be.
  • A life outside of work. Working all the time ironically decreases your productivity.
  • Faith and Belief. Meaning and purpose make a big difference.

The good news is all of these are in your control.

The easiest place to start is to get some rest. Why not begin there tonight?

At the most basic level, success is getting up one more time than you were knocked down. Click To Tweet

3. Agility

The best kind of leadership style in uncertainty is agile leadership.

Agile leadership is flexible leadership, the ability to pivot and change not just once but as often as changing conditions warrant.

When the future is unpredictable, agility is ability. Flexibility is a superpower.

The reason agility is so important is that a crisis means there are no clear answers and no immediate end in sight. This is exactly why it’s called a crisis, not a problem.

Problems can be solved. Crises have to be managed. Daily.

As we move into the year ahead, it looks like crisis management will be a skill set required of every leader as we head into an unpredictable future.

When the future is unpredictable, agility is ability. Flexibility is a superpower. Click To Tweet

4. Emotional Health

As a leader (or as a human), you are only as healthy as you are emotionally healthy.

Church leaders who claim to be spiritually healthy but are emotionally unhealthy aren’t healthy.  Ditto with business leaders who claim to be great at what they do—a lack of emotional health causes a lot of collateral damage and ultimately can lead to collapse.

My journey to becoming more emotionally healthy took years and involved a lot of prayer, counseling, coaching, and feedback.

Pete Scazzero’s work on emotional health for leaders has been game-changing for so many leaders, including me. If you want an introduction to Pete’s work, here’s my latest conversation with him.

As a leader (or as a human), you are only as healthy as you are emotionally healthy.  Click To Tweet

5. The Stockdale Paradox

Let’s finish up by going back to what Jim Collins calls Stockdale Paradox, one of the principles that a lot of leaders talked about early on in the crisis.

As you may remember, Jim Stockdale was an American Vise Admiral captured and imprisoned during the Vietnam War. He was held and tortured for seven years.

Stockdale said the first people to die in captivity were the optimists, who kept thinking things would get better quickly and they’d be released. “They died of a broken heart,” Stockdale said.

Instead, Stockdale argued, the key to survival was to combine realism and hope.  In Stockdale’s words:

“This is a very important lesson. You must never confuse faith that you will prevail in the end–-which you can never afford to lose–-with the discipline to confront the most brutal facts of your current reality, whatever they might be.”

That, essentially, is your job in crisis leadership. The greatest leaders confront the brutal facts but never lose hope.

The greatest leaders confront the brutal facts but never lose hope. Click To Tweet

You’ve prepared your sermon. You’re ready for Sunday... Or are you?

The #1 factor people look for in a church is the quality of the preaching. In fact, 86% of people choose a church based on that.

So if you step back and take a look in the mirror for a moment...

  • Does your sermon prep get the time it deserves?
  • And when was the last time you took a big step forward in becoming a better preacher?

Most Pastors aren't happy with the answers they give to those questions.

How to preach more engaging, memorable, and relevant sermons—starting as early as this week.

Now, take a minute to imagine feeling confident that your message would connect on Sunday morning, knowing you’d deliver it clearly and truthfully.

It’s time to ditch the random, stressful, and last-minute approach to becoming a better preacher and communicator.

Get a proven method to preach sermons that reach more people and grow your church in The Art of Preaching. It's the only program trusted by 3,000+ pastors over 5+ years—no matter the denomination or church size—that will transform your preaching from preparation to delivery.

  • You’ll save hours each week with a better sermon prep process.
  • You’ll write messages people remember for months… or even years.
  • You’ll deepen your own connection with the text, seeing things you never noticed before.
  • You’ll be able to (finally) deliver your message without using notes.
  • You’ll preach sermons that reach more people and transform the lives of churched and unchurched people alike.
Share This Post
Carey Nieuwhof
Carey Nieuwhof

Carey Nieuwhof is a best-selling leadership author, speaker, podcaster, former attorney, and church planter. He hosts one of today’s most influential leadership podcasts, and his online content is accessed by leaders over 1.5 million times a month. He speaks to leaders around the world about leadership, change, and personal growth.